Should transgender athletes be allowed to compete?

Trigger warning: This post may go against popular opinion, but somebody has to say it. A while back I read an article on Cycling Tips about a male cyclist who had transitioned and was now competing in the elite women’s peloton. It sparked discussion of course and a lot of support. It’s a brave thing to do and going through that transition can’t be easy. Since that article Jillian has gone on to take a few wins.

Most people seemed supportive. Call me sceptical, but I wonder how many of the women competing against Jillian were secretly NOT okay with it. We should of course be aiming for a system that supports diversity and inclusion, but as much as modern culture would like to have you believe it, men and women are not physically equal. It’s genetics, deal with it.

Transgender professional cyclist, Jillian Bearden (CyclingTips).

Transgender professional cyclist, Rachel McKinnon.

The issue hit the spotlight again this week. At the Commonwealth Games, transgender athlete Laurel Hubbard was competing in the women’s weightlifting over 90kg division. Fine, right? Sure. I have nothing against the transgender community.  Laurel transitioned at the age of 35 and beforehand spent many years competing at an international level as Gavin, a man. Let’s just lay that out: Assuming weight training since the age of 15, that’s a full 20 years of high-testosterone fuelled muscle building as a man. That’s some advantage.

Let’s face it. Men and women at the elite level of physically competitive sports are NOT equal. Our weightlifter example set Junior records AS A MAN before transitioning. In the 2017 Oceania Champs Laurel won gold with a total of 273kg in the women’s comp, second place Luniarra Sipaia lifted 250kg total (the equivalent male class winner lifted 341kg total).

Transgender athlete, Laurel Hubbard competing for New Zealand.

Call me transphobic or LBGTQI negative whatever buzzword you want to create this week, but I say if you’re competing at a professional level, competing for large cash prizes, for places on National teams, for gold medals; take a DNA test. If it comes back male, you compete with the men.

I believe there is a place for transgender athletes in professional sport, but a genetic male competing as a female may not be that place. Sure that may hurt some people’s feelings and it may not fit in with today’s political correct agendas – but life is tough and it’s time to toughen up. Equality only goes so far.

Three time TdF stage winner Robert Millar transitioned after retirement.


End Note: At the end of the day it became a moot point at the Commonwealth Games, as Laurel had to retire from the competition due to injury. Samoa’s Feagaiga Stowers went on to win Gold.

5 Comments Add yours

  1. I am with you. Genetics do play a part and if they have already competed as one gender , they should stay with that gender for competing .

    Liked by 1 person

  2. sevencyclist says:

    Just to play devil’s advocate, I wonder … what kind of performance a person would get, while they were still male, compared to after the surgery, and performing the same event as a female. I guess it wouldn’t make any difference, but just food for thought.

    Like

    1. bgddyjim says:

      That would depend on whether or not they take their hormone therapy or not. It has nothing to do with an operation.

      Also, do you really want to advocate for the devil? You go right on ahead, thanks for calling it what it is.

      Liked by 2 people

    2. There’d definitely be a difference in strength based sports if they’re on hormone therapy, as reduced testosterone levels would come into play. Still all that time training as a man would provide some advantage!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. bgddyjim says:

    I’m with you, man. Too easy to cheat – or so it would seem.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s